Some DJI Phantom Users are Experiencing Flyaways Resulting in Lost/Damaged Units and Cameras | Page 4 | News | Forum

email

Please consider registering
guest

Log In Register

Register | Lost password?
Advanced Search

— Forum Scope —

  

— Match —

   

— Forum Options —

   

Wildcard usage:
*  matches any number of characters    %  matches exactly one character

Minimum search word length is 4 characters - maximum search word length is 84 characters

Topic RSS
Some DJI Phantom Users are Experiencing Flyaways Resulting in Lost/Damaged Units and Cameras
Read the original blog post
June 11, 2014
7:05 am
madgadget
New Member
Forum Posts: 1
Member Since:
June 11, 2014
Offline

Apologies for this long post (which I also posted on the DJIGuys.com forum as well), but I have just experienced an altogether shocking situation with DJI and the more I think about it, the more something is seriously wrong with the Phantom platform. I'm not trying to scaremonger people, but the experience I had over the past few days has left me wondering….

A bit of background first, as when all this happened, I did think for one moment I was going mad. I've been flying RC Heli's in stunt and scale form for 20 years, member of the BMFA and pride myself with being able to fly carefully and safely. I still fly a range of Align and Century Heli's (electric and glow fuel) and also have some of the smaller drones such as the Hubsan H107C/D and the Parrot Ar Drone. I've flown both FM and currently fly the Futaba FASST 2.4Ghz platform and never ever had any control or signal problems. The only time in 20 years that I crashed a Heli was because I was getting far to confident in new stunts and pushed the limit, that said, I've only crashed twice.

So, watching the Phantom platform with great interest, I was about to buy the P2V when they announced the P2V+. Great, I managed to find one last wednesday via a dealer and bought it and it arrived on Friday.

On Saturday morning, I went through all of the usual inspection checks and I also hooked up the Phantom to the computer and uploaded the latest firmware (v3.04), checked calibrations etc. Everything was good and the battery was freshly charged. A short preflight in the garden went well and confirmed that it could get a lock for GPS etc.

So, Saturday early evening, I took the P2V+ out into the garden and did all the normal preflight checks, switches correct, controller on, Wifi extender on, iPhone on Airplane mode but with Wifi on and connected to the range extender and the iPhone app started up. 

I then checked all the props and removed the camera gimbal stabiliser and switched on the Phantom and carried out the compass calibration. Then placed it on the ground and waited whilst watching the satellite acquisition. Finally, 7 satellites signalled by rapid green flashing of the rear LEDs and then onto slow green flashing meant that it has a GPS lock and also recorded it's home position (according to the manual, website etc).

I lifted off and the phantom hovered, went up to 100ft above and in front, tail in, point away from me. Then all of a suddenly it started to climb and the controls become unresponsive, I then tried to dump it by shutting down the motors but no response, although the iPhone app was still receiving telemetry, the controls were not working. I then turned off the controller to initiate the return to home and that did not work. The last I saw of the phantom and the last the iPhone app saw was it climbing past 248ft at a speed of 24.8mph and flying away. 

I live on the edge of the salisbury plain and it went off towards woodland and acres of rape seed crop (which are about 4 ft tall and very thick). A search party over the saturday evening and sunday failed to find it. I have since had to work with the Police and the MOD (as it's on the edge of the salisbury plain) just in case it is found.

Now here's where I get to the really shocking and concerning part.

I was under the impression from forums, DJI's good website, marketing etc that the Phantom is failsafe, reliable, trustworthy and more importantly, safe. But, I do not believe that is the case. I really don't. Whilst I still have my Heli's and other drones, they have never, ever lost control, if they have, that would be down to me and that is important if and when you fly near to other people, property etc, which I try to avoid as much as possible.

I do believe however, that the fact that this drone is hooked up to a computer and GPS, that somewhere in there is a fundamental flaw that a) caused this to occur and to fly away, but more importantly causes me to completely scrap any idea that using this platform could be a good business venture. 

OK, so it could be said that the majority of people have never experienced a loss of control or fly away, fine. But given that since Sunday (4 days ago) when I started looking into 'Phantom flyways' as they have been coined, I found 5 other people in the last few days who have experience this, any degree of 'unsafe' around this platform should put a big black flag onto it, until it can be guaranteed to be reliable and safe, especially given it's size.

I have since written to DJI on several occasions, but so far not heard anything. I followed all of the pre and during flight safety checks, but still this flyaway occurred and to watch something like £900 fly away without your control inputs working is, well, gutting. Fortunately, it did not fly into one of the neighbours houses, cars etc.

There are numerous websites where people are contributing to this problem:

https://www.facebook.com/djiflyaway , 
http://www.photographybay.com/2013/07/2 … d-cameras/

that second page shows that this was kicking off mid 2013 as well, so this is not unknown to DJI.

and there is another flyer Eric Riemer (eric@architech3di.com) who is pulling together a list of any of those people who experience this problem. 

I really really didn't want to criticise this platform, I was hoping to do great things with it, the photo/video quality is simply awesome. But, with this fundamental design flaw, it is more of a random, incredibly dangerous drone and I could never trust it near people. Great design but flawed execution.

I hope that something good comes of this and that others do not experience what I and a growing number of other flyers out there are also experiencing.

Sorry for the long and windy posting, but hopefully, you will see that this is not just a sad issue, but it is a dangerous issue :)

email
June 11, 2014
10:17 pm
eriemer
Member
Forum Posts: 6
Member Since:
June 11, 2014
Offline
62

David said
I Have had the same issue happen yesterday – I have been flying for many months and this is the first time this has happened….
Heres the video

I am getting a lawsuit together. Many of us have had the same problem and the lack of response from DJI is sad. I have a growing group of individuals who had the same experience and we are filing a lawsuit. We will be filing in the next week or two, so please contact me if you would like to join.

Eric

Eric@architech3di.com

email
June 11, 2014
10:18 pm
eriemer
Member
Forum Posts: 6
Member Since:
June 11, 2014
Offline
63

madgadget said
Apologies for this long post (which I also posted on the DJIGuys.com forum as well), but I have just experienced an altogether shocking situation with DJI and the more I think about it, the more something is seriously wrong with the Phantom platform. I'm not trying to scaremonger people, but the experience I had over the past few days has left me wondering….

A bit of background first, as when all this happened, I did think for one moment I was going mad. I've been flying RC Heli's in stunt and scale form for 20 years, member of the BMFA and pride myself with being able to fly carefully and safely. I still fly a range of Align and Century Heli's (electric and glow fuel) and also have some of the smaller drones such as the Hubsan H107C/D and the Parrot Ar Drone. I've flown both FM and currently fly the Futaba FASST 2.4Ghz platform and never ever had any control or signal problems. The only time in 20 years that I crashed a Heli was because I was getting far to confident in new stunts and pushed the limit, that said, I've only crashed twice.

So, watching the Phantom platform with great interest, I was about to buy the P2V when they announced the P2V+. Great, I managed to find one last wednesday via a dealer and bought it and it arrived on Friday.

On Saturday morning, I went through all of the usual inspection checks and I also hooked up the Phantom to the computer and uploaded the latest firmware (v3.04), checked calibrations etc. Everything was good and the battery was freshly charged. A short preflight in the garden went well and confirmed that it could get a lock for GPS etc.

So, Saturday early evening, I took the P2V+ out into the garden and did all the normal preflight checks, switches correct, controller on, Wifi extender on, iPhone on Airplane mode but with Wifi on and connected to the range extender and the iPhone app started up. 

I then checked all the props and removed the camera gimbal stabiliser and switched on the Phantom and carried out the compass calibration. Then placed it on the ground and waited whilst watching the satellite acquisition. Finally, 7 satellites signalled by rapid green flashing of the rear LEDs and then onto slow green flashing meant that it has a GPS lock and also recorded it's home position (according to the manual, website etc).

I lifted off and the phantom hovered, went up to 100ft above and in front, tail in, point away from me. Then all of a suddenly it started to climb and the controls become unresponsive, I then tried to dump it by shutting down the motors but no response, although the iPhone app was still receiving telemetry, the controls were not working. I then turned off the controller to initiate the return to home and that did not work. The last I saw of the phantom and the last the iPhone app saw was it climbing past 248ft at a speed of 24.8mph and flying away. 

I live on the edge of the salisbury plain and it went off towards woodland and acres of rape seed crop (which are about 4 ft tall and very thick). A search party over the saturday evening and sunday failed to find it. I have since had to work with the Police and the MOD (as it's on the edge of the salisbury plain) just in case it is found.

Now here's where I get to the really shocking and concerning part.

I was under the impression from forums, DJI's good website, marketing etc that the Phantom is failsafe, reliable, trustworthy and more importantly, safe. But, I do not believe that is the case. I really don't. Whilst I still have my Heli's and other drones, they have never, ever lost control, if they have, that would be down to me and that is important if and when you fly near to other people, property etc, which I try to avoid as much as possible.

I do believe however, that the fact that this drone is hooked up to a computer and GPS, that somewhere in there is a fundamental flaw that a) caused this to occur and to fly away, but more importantly causes me to completely scrap any idea that using this platform could be a good business venture. 

OK, so it could be said that the majority of people have never experienced a loss of control or fly away, fine. But given that since Sunday (4 days ago) when I started looking into 'Phantom flyways' as they have been coined, I found 5 other people in the last few days who have experience this, any degree of 'unsafe' around this platform should put a big black flag onto it, until it can be guaranteed to be reliable and safe, especially given it's size.

I have since written to DJI on several occasions, but so far not heard anything. I followed all of the pre and during flight safety checks, but still this flyaway occurred and to watch something like £900 fly away without your control inputs working is, well, gutting. Fortunately, it did not fly into one of the neighbours houses, cars etc.

There are numerous websites where people are contributing to this problem:

https://www.facebook.com/djiflyaway , 
http://www.photographybay.com/2013/07/2 … d-cameras/

that second page shows that this was kicking off mid 2013 as well, so this is not unknown to DJI.

and there is another flyer Eric Riemer (eric@architech3di.com) who is pulling together a list of any of those people who experience this problem. 

I really really didn't want to criticise this platform, I was hoping to do great things with it, the photo/video quality is simply awesome. But, with this fundamental design flaw, it is more of a random, incredibly dangerous drone and I could never trust it near people. Great design but flawed execution.

I hope that something good comes of this and that others do not experience what I and a growing number of other flyers out there are also experiencing.

Sorry for the long and windy posting, but hopefully, you will see that this is not just a sad issue, but it is a dangerous issue :)

I am getting a lawsuit together. Many of us have had the same problem and the lack of response from DJI is sad. I have a growing group of individuals who had the same experience and we are filing a lawsuit. We will be filing in the next week or two, so please contact me if you would like to join.

Eric

Eric@architech3di.com

email
June 11, 2014
10:20 pm
eriemer
Member
Forum Posts: 6
Member Since:
June 11, 2014
Offline
64

valcalepi said
March 27th 5:20pm EST I had the same fly away issue and I spent 2 days in the forest, marsh, river and landfills trying to find it.

Had  a brand new Mobius Camera mounted on my DJI Phantom FC40. $660 invested, it seems after reading all these posts that this is a wide spread problem. I also had issues after performing firmware update, the software changed the config to another transmitter(one I do not have). I have to wait 90 minutes on hold for DJI to tell me the fix. Why not send a new firmware out that corrects the bug. Clearly they have issues with their products. I am on hold to speak to someone I was caller 42 but got down to 22 so far and waiting.

 

When I called earlier I was caller 9, I should have stayed on the call then ;-(

 

With that many support calls, it shows there is an issue and their firmware has a bug!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!ConfusedFrownYell

I am getting a lawsuit together. Many of us have had the same problem and the lack of response from DJI is sad. I have a growing group of individuals who had the same experience and we are filing a lawsuit. We will be filing in the next week or two, so please contact me if you would like to join.

Eric

Eric@architech3di.com

email
June 11, 2014
10:21 pm
eriemer
Member
Forum Posts: 6
Member Since:
June 11, 2014
Offline
65

john uk said
i had the same problem yesterday i flew mine set the compass corectly took the model to near enuff 400ft" i lost control of it as it said conection failed, so i decided to switch off the transmitter and let it return to home' after switching off the transmitter it did say going home on my iphone" but after 5 seconds after powering of that transmitter it said conection faild" however i remember looking at my phone screen i was conected to 9 satelites" the model had a mind of its own it just start flying away" i realised it was not responding to return to home my camra switched off i tryd turning my transmitter back on to regain control but by that time it had flown so far away i was unable to get it back" battry was also fully charged this happened with that latest phantom vision 2" £850 loss in under 2weeks model was never to be seen or heard from" 

 

dji need to fix up and get this dam robot workjng properly as its an expensive thing to loose" :( good luck everyone 

hope this does not happen to others

 

I am getting a lawsuit together. Many of us have had the same problem and the lack of response from DJI is sad. I have a growing group of individuals who had the same experience and we are filing a lawsuit. We will be filing in the next week or two, so please contact me if you would like to join.

Eric

Eric@architech3di.com

email
June 11, 2014
10:22 pm
eriemer
Member
Forum Posts: 6
Member Since:
June 11, 2014
Offline
66

Railhound said
I had flown my Phantom 2 about 10 times. Everything seemed to work just fine. On my last flight everything started normally the lights were green indicating ready to fly with GPS support. I was connected with the camera and could see the ground on my smartphone.

As soon as I spun up the rotors, I began as normal with a slow ascent and then all of a sudden the Phantom 2 just shot straight up in the air and flew away over my house. I attempted to bring the aircraft back down but it appeared that I had no control of the aircraft at all. The connection to the camera was also lost almost immediately after take off.

I quickly lost sight of the aircraft. I turned the controller off assuming it would return to home but it did not. I walked around my neighborhood searching for the aircraft and trying to see if I could reconnect somehow to the camera and aircraft or spot where it was.

The aircraft is now lost. This is a very dangerous situation as it could have crashed and hurt someone. I have no idea where the Phantom 2 landed or if it crashed. However, I am uncertain that I want a replacement unit now as obviously there is a serious flaw in the manufacture of this product (or this particular unit was defective.) In any case, this created an extremely dangerous situation.

It is obvious that this had nothing to do with WIFI signals in the area. The fail safe should have return the unit to home. Judging from the rest of the posts here this design flaw was carried over from the Phantom to the Phantom 2.

I have emailed both the dealer and DJI but haven't heard from them yet. My advice – don't but this device. It is dangerous – never mind costly.

I am getting a lawsuit together. Many of us have had the same problem and the lack of response from DJI is sad. I have a growing group of individuals who had the same experience and we are filing a lawsuit. We will be filing in the next week or two, so please contact me if you would like to join.

Eric

Eric@architech3di.com

email
June 12, 2014
9:09 pm
learj25
New Member
Forum Posts: 1
Member Since:
June 12, 2014
Offline
67

I've had mine about 2 weeks and today the thing went straight to the ground. It was like I had full down with the gains why up "wobbling " very fast. I was about 200-300 ft away and 100 ft high. Luckily, I jumped on my golf cart and found it sitting upright with the battery tossed out. Brought it home put a new battery in and everything appeared to work fine. I am very concerned that this thing can be dangerous. It happened when I shut the radio off to return home then trying to regain control. I went to att mode then it happened. Very concerned! 

email
July 8, 2014
11:54 am
jensjk
New Member
Forum Posts: 1
Member Since:
July 8, 2014
Offline
68

I have been flying the Phantoms for more than a year, and think I know the stuff about RTH. Nevertheless, I have recently lost my Phantom Vision.
I was about 150 m away from me, height 30-35 meters, when I lost visual contact (against the sun) and due to nearby heavy machinery I couldn't use my hearing neither. And the display on my phone reported "control signal lost". Believeing in RTH I waited a few minutes – but no, it never turned up. In "Find my Phantom" I could see the last position in a completely wrong direction. Followed that track – nothing. And I did have a good GPS fix before starting out.

The other loss was of a Phantom 1.2.1, equipped with Ground Station and FPV. Admittedly, I had been flying in an altitude of 100 meters, when I lost contact, Again, RTH didn't work, and I could hear it flying off, some high treees barring me from seeing it and giving bad FPV. I could just hear the sound getting more and more remote, fading out – there was plenty of battery (equipped with 2x2.8 A). Not recovered, probably lost in a barley field.

My suggestion is loss of GPS-signal, making the P sensitive to the prevailing wind. But I think I am done with DJI – at least for some time – losing two (and two Gopros)

email
July 12, 2014
2:59 pm
ricky6120
New Member
Forum Posts: 1
Member Since:
July 12, 2014
Offline
69

Brand new! 1st Flight a flyaway, found it, found your blog Im in on any lawsuit. My teenage son was wanting me to help him with his movie making and i was going to shoot some arial footage and surprise him. Isnt that how dji phantom advertises? Extremely disappointed!!

email
Forum Timezone: America/New_York

Most Users Ever Online: 464

Currently Online:
7 Guest(s)

Currently Browsing this Page:
1 Guest(s)

Top Posters:

eriemer: 6

byroninedmonton: 3

Cristi: 2

photography: 2

moniteur: 2

catfish252: 2

Kortney Jarman: 2

dswatson83: 2

stevenjoen: 2

marcus: 2

Member Stats:

Guest Posters: 794

Members: 320

Moderators: 0

Admins: 1

Forum Stats:

Groups: 3

Forums: 5

Topics: 1722

Posts: 3052

Newest Members: cwilliams, fxks323, Hunter McRae, ojarshiz, pieropereira, HenryRamosELP, ricky6120, jensjk, preethi

Administrators: Eric Reagan (1782)